Ranking najlepszych studyjnych utworów PH - "Nadir..."

Sylvie · 11 Czerwiec 2009, 20:31:19

Nadir's Big Chance (1975)

1. Nadir's Big Chance
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning
3. Open Your Eyes
4. Nobody's Business
5. Been Alone So Long
6. Pompeii
7. Shingle Song
8. Airport
9. People You Were Going To
10. Birthday Special
11. Two or Three Spectres

Sylvie · 11 Czerwiec 2009, 20:35:05

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10
3. Open Your Eyes - 9
4. Nobody's Business - 9
5. Been Alone So Long - 10
6. Pompeii - 9
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 10
9. People You Were Going To - 9
10. Birthday Special - 9
11. Two or Three Spectres - 9

Sebastian Winter · 11 Czerwiec 2009, 21:38:30

Nadir czyli punkowa plyta z czasow kiedy jeszcze punka nie bylo...az trudno uwiezyć ze ta sama ekipa nagrala pozniej Godbluffa

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10-za powera i partie gitary
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10 za pojechany tekst
3. Open Your Eyes - 10- za klimat
4. Nobody's Business -10- za punkową energię
5. Been Alone So Long -10- za piękno
6. Pompeii - 6- chyba najslabszy na plycie
7. Shingle Song -12- kolejna moja najukochansza piesn PH-a do tego ten tekst- nigdy nie zapomne tych mrocznych dni sprzed 7 lat kiedy ciągle sobie nucilem: And I can't get you out of my mind, no, no, no, no, I just can't get you from my mind.
8. Airport - 10 -za smutek
9. People You Were Going To- 8-jakoś sie nigdy nie moglem do niej przekonać
10. Birthday Special-10-
11. Two or Three Spectres-9-za odjechany klimat

ceizurac · 11 Czerwiec 2009, 21:45:36

Cytat: Sebastian Winter w 11 Czerwiec 2009, 21:38:30
Nadir czyli punkowa plyta z czasow kiedy jeszcze punka nie bylo...az trudno uwiezyć ze ta sama ekipa nagrala pozniej Godbluffa

Shingle Song -12- kolejna moja najukochansza piesn PH-a do tego ten tekst- nigdy nie zapomne tych mrocznych dni sprzed 7 lat kiedy ciągle sobie nucilem: And I can't get you out of my mind, no, no, no, no, I just can't get you from my mind.

"Shingle" najlepiej brzmi z akustyczną gitarą i Hammillem śpiewającym początek i koniec acapella...

A z tym fragmentem tekstu całkowicie się utożsamiam... Chociaż studyjna wersja ma ten żałośnie smutny saksofon...

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10
3. Open Your Eyes - 10
4. Nobody's Business - 10
5. Been Alone So Long - 10
6. Pompeii - 10
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 10
9. People You Were Going To - 10
10. Birthday Special - 10
11. Two or Three Spectres - 10

Daję same 10-tki bez wahania; uwielbiam Nadira jako całość - trudno mi tu wyróżnić jakąkolwiek piosenkę.

Hennos · 12 Czerwiec 2009, 03:00:04

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10
3. Open Your Eyes - 10
4. Nobody's Business - 10
5. Been Alone So Long - 10
6. Pompeii - 9
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 10
9. People You Were Going To - 7
10. Birthday Special - 9
11. Two or Three Spectres - 9

Polset · 12 Czerwiec 2009, 11:19:51

1. Nadir's Big Chance-10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning-10
3. Open Your Eyes-10
4. Nobody's Business-10
5. Been Alone So Long-10
6. Pompeii-4
7. Shingle Song-8
8. Airport-10
9. People You Were Going To-8
10. Birthday Special-10
11. Two or Three Spectres-10

Tamara · 12 Czerwiec 2009, 16:35:21

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10
3. Open Your Eyes - 10
4. Nobody's Business - 10
5. Been Alone So Long - 10
6. Pompeii - 10
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 10
9. People You Were Going To - 10
10. Birthday Special - 10
11. Two or Three Spectres - 10

Martha · 12 Czerwiec 2009, 20:35:25

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10
3. Open Your Eyes - 10
4. Nobody's Business - 10
5. Been Alone So Long - 10
6. Pompeii - 10
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 10
9. People You Were Going To - 10
10. Birthday Special - 10
11. Two or Three Spectres - 10

dziobak · 13 Czerwiec 2009, 11:55:35

1. Nadir's Big Chance...................................7
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning.......6
3. Open Your Eyes......................................7
4. Nobody's Business...................................6
5. Been Alone So Long ...............................8
6. Pompeii ................................................7
7. Shingle Song.........................................10
8. Airport.................................................8
9. People You Were Going To ......................7
10. Birthday Special....................................6
11. Two or Three Spectres...........................7

Desdemona · 13 Czerwiec 2009, 16:28:55

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 10
3. Open Your Eyes - 9
4. Nobody's Business - 9
5. Been Alone So Long - 9
6. Pompeii - 8
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 9
9. People You Were Going To - 8
10. Birthday Special - 9
11. Two or Three Spectres - 9

Kuba · 13 Czerwiec 2009, 20:45:01

Mega album

.

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 8
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 6,5
3. Open Your Eyes - 7
4. Nobody's Business - 8
5. Been Alone So Long - 10
6. Pompeii - 5
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 7,5
9. People You Were Going To - 7,5
10. Birthday Special - 8,5
11. Two or Three Spectres - 8

ceizurac · 16 Czerwiec 2009, 15:04:25

Po 10 głosach:

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 9,7 (97 p.)
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 9,25 (92,5 p.)
3. Open Your Eyes - 9,2 (92 p.)
4. Nobody's Business - 9,3 (93 p.)
5. Been Alone So Long - 9,7 (97 p.)
6. Pompeii - 7,8 (78 p.)
7. Shingle Song - 10 (100 p.)
8. Airport - 9,45 (94,5 p.)
9. People You Were Going To - 8,45 (84,5 p.)
10. Birthday Special - 9,1 (91 p.)
11. Two or Three Spectres - 9,2 (92 p.)

Średnia albumu (będzie wysoka) - 9,2 (1012 p./110)

Mazo · 20 Czerwiec 2009, 22:27:45

1. Nadir's Big Chance 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning 8
3. Open Your Eyes 10
4. Nobody's Business 9
5. Been Alone So Long 10
6. Pompeii 9
7. Shingle Song 9
8. Airport 10
9. People You Were Going To 9
10. Birthday Special 7
11. Two or Three Spectres 7

ceizurac · 20 Czerwiec 2009, 23:34:38

Po 11 głosach:

Shingle Song - 9,91 (109 p.)
Nadir's Big Chance - 9,73 (107 p.)
Been Alone So Long - 9,73 (107 p.)
Airport - 9,5 (104,5 p.)
Open Your Eyes - 9,27 (102 p.)
Nobody's Business - 9,27 (102 p.)
The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 9,14 (100,5 p.)
Two or Three Spectres - 9 (99 p.)
Birthday Special - 8,91 (98 p.)
People You Were Going To - 8,5 (93,5 p.)
Pompeii - 7,91 (87 p.)

Średnia albumu - 9,17 (1110 p./121)

Hajduk · 27 Czerwiec 2009, 21:35:22

1. Nadir's Big Chance - 10
2. The Institute of Mental Health, Burning - 8,5
3. Open Your Eyes (The Locarno Song) - 9
4. Nobody's Business - 8,5
5. Been Alone So Long - 9,5
6. Pompeii - 7
7. Shingle Song - 10
8. Airport - 6,5
9. People You Were Going To - 9
10. Birthday Special - 9
11. Two or Three Spectres - 10

Aktualności:

Ranking najlepszych studyjnych utworów PH - "Nadir..."

Desdemona