"Ship of Fools" - polskie forum VdGG / PH
Peter Hammill => Dyskusja hammillowa => Wielkie głosowanie - PH => Wątek zaczęty przez: Sylvie w 11 Czerwca 2009, 21:56:28
-
Roaring Forties (1994)
1. Sharply Unclear
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed)
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey)
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get....
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet
6. A Headlong Strech
7. Your Tall Ship
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 8
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 9
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 9
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 8
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 8
6. A Headlong Strech - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 9
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 7
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 9
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 9
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 8
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 8
6. A Headlong Strech - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 8
-
1. Sharply Unclear-10
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed)-9
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey)-9
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get....-6
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet-5
6. A Headlong Strech-10
7. Your Tall Ship-10
-
1. Sharply Unclear- 10
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) -7
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 10
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get....-7
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet -10
6. A Headlong Strech -10
7. Your Tall Ship -9
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 9
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 9
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 9
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 8
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 8
6. A Headlong Strech - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 8
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 7
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 8
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 8
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 8
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 8
6. A Headlong Strech - 8
7. Your Tall Ship - 10
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 8
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 6
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 8
6. A Headlong Strech - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 9
-
1. Sharply Unclear..............................................8
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed).............................7
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey)............................6
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get................7
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet..............................6
6. A Headlong Strech..........................................7
7. Your Tall Ship ...............................................8
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 7
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 5
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7
6. A Headlong Strech - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 8
-
Po 9 głosach:
A Headlong Strech - 9,44 (85 p.)
Your Tall Ship - 8,78 (79 p.)
Sharply Unclear - 8,22 (74 p.)
The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 8 (72 p.)
...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,56 (68 p.)
You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7,33 (66 p.)
The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 7,22 (65 p.)
Nowość - średnia dla całego albumu 8,08.
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 10
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 9
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 7
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7
6. A Headlong Strech - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 8
-
Po 10 głosach:
A Headlong Strech - 9,5 (95 p.)
Your Tall Ship - 8,7 (87 p.)
Sharply Unclear - 8,4 (84 p.)
The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 8,1 (81 p.)
...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,5 (75 p.)
You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7,3 (73 p.)
The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 7,3 (73 p.)
Nowość - średnia dla całego albumu 8,11 (568 p./70)
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 9
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 8
3. The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 8
4. You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 8
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 8
6. A Headlong Strech - 11
7. Your Tall Ship - 9
-
Po 11 głosach:
A Headlong Strech - 9,64 (106 p.)
Your Tall Ship - 8,73 (96 p.)
Sharply Unclear - 8,45 (93 p.)
The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 8,09 (89 p.)
...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,54 (83 p.)
You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7,36 (81 p.)
The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 7,36 (81 p.)
Nowość - średnia dla całego albumu 8,17 (629 p./77)
-
Roaring Forties (1994)
1. Sharply Unclear - 9,5
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 8
3. The Gift Of Fire (Talk Turkey) - 7
4. You Can't Want What You Always Get... - 9,5
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 10
6. A Headlong Strech - 9
7. Your Tall Ship - 3
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 6
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 3
3. The Gift Of Fire (Talk Turkey) - 2
4. You Can't Want What You Always Get... - 2
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 2
6. A Headlong Stretch - 13
7. Your Tall Ship - 10
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 6
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 3
3. The Gift Of Fire (Talk Turkey) - 2
4. You Can't Want What You Always Get... - 2
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 2
6. A Headlong Strech - 13
7. Your Tall Ship - 10
widze ze Kolega Wobbler niezbyt lubi te plyte
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 6
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 3
3. The Gift Of Fire (Talk Turkey) - 2
4. You Can't Want What You Always Get... - 2
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 2
6. A Headlong Strech - 13
7. Your Tall Ship - 10
widze ze Kolega Wobbler niezbyt lubi te plyte
Płyta jest dla mnie genialna pod warunkiem, że nie słucham utworów od 2 do 5
Headlong Stretch w połączeniu z Your Tall Ship tworzą niesamowitą kompozycję i w sumie to mi wystarczy aby wielbić tą płytę.
-
Po 13 głosach:
A Headlong Stretch - 9,85 (128 p.)
Your Tall Ship - 8,38 (109 p.)
Sharply Unclear - 8,35 (108,5 p.)
The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7,69 (100 p.)
...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,31 (95 p.)
You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7,11 (92,5 p.)
The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 6,92 (90 p.)
Średnia dla całego albumu 7,94 (723 p./91)
-
Ceizuracu popraw błąd w pisowni Headlong Stretch bo od początku ktoś źle napisał i wszyscy tak kopiują.
-
Ceizuracu popraw błąd w pisowni Headlong Stretch bo od początku ktoś źle napisał i wszyscy tak kopiują.
Zaraz to poprawię, dzięki.
A ty popraw swój ostatni przekład, bo znalazłam błąd i chyba nadal on tam jest ;)
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 9
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7,5
3. The Gift Of Fire (Talk Turkey) - 9 [ciekawy przypadek, bo Hammill w podobnym wydaniu dotąd mi nie leżał, a ta kompozycja długo "siedziała mi w głowie"]
4. You Can't Want What You Always Get... - 5 [zbyt głośny, dziwne - zupełnie nie "moje" - hardrockowe klimaty]
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,5
6. A Headlong Stretch - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 9,5
Dobry album, no może poza jednym "rodzynkiem". ;)
-
Po 14 głosach:
A Headlong Stretch - 9,86 (138 p.)
Your Tall Ship - 8,46 (118,5 p.)
Sharply Unclear - 8,39 (117,5 p.)
The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7,68 (107,5 p.)
...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,32 (102,5 p.)
The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 7,07 (99 p.)
You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 6,96 (97,5 p.)
Średnia dla całego albumu 7,96 (780,5 p./98)
-
1. Sharply Unclear - 9
2. The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7
3. The Gift Of Fire (Talk Turkey) - 7
4. You Can't Want What You Always Get... - 9
5. ...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 10
6. A Headlong Stretch - 10
7. Your Tall Ship - 5
-
Po 15 głosach:
A Headlong Stretch - 9,87 (148 p.)
Sharply Unclear - 8,43 (126,5 p.)
Your Tall Ship - 8,23 (123,5 p.)
The Gift Of Fire (Precursed) - 7,63 (114,5 p.)
...If You Haven't Got It Yet - 7,5 (112,5 p.)
You Can't Want What you Always Get.... - 7,1 (106,5 p.)
The Gift Of fire (Talk Turkey) - 7,07 (106 p.)
Średnia dla całego albumu 7,98 (837,5 p./105)