Ranking najlepszych studyjnych utworów PH - "Thin Air"

Zaczęty przez Sylvie, 11 Czerwiec 2009, 22:51:01

Poprzedni wątek - Następny wątek

0 użytkowników i 1 Gość przegląda ten wątek.

Martha

Waiting for the doctor to come.

ceizurac

Po 10 głosach:

The Mercy - 11,8 (118 p.)
The Top of the World Club - 9,8 (98 p.)
Your Face on the Street - 9,6 (96 p.)
Stumbled - 9,6 (96 p.)
Wrong Way Round - 9,5 (95 p.)
Undone - 9,5 (95 p.)
Diminished - 9,5 (95 p.)
If We Must Part Like this - 9,2 (92 p.)
Ghost of Planes - 9 (90 p.)

Średnia albumu - 9,72 (875 p./90)

Średnie wg głosujących:
Sylwia - 10,44
Martha - 10,33
Desdemona - 10,33
Tamara - 10,22
Hennos - 10,22
Polset - 10,11
Sebastian - 10
Ceizurac - 9,33
Frippotronic - 9,11
Dziobak - 7,11
There's the thing, hold it close.
You had your fling. You laid your ghosts.

Time to leave, close the door.
You can't believe you wanted more,
more or less, al for the best
in the end it's al behind you.

There's the thing, for all you know
it's time to let go.

Kuba

#17
1. The Mercy - 10
2. Your Face on the Street - 8,5
3. Stumbled - 7
4. Wrong Way Round - 9
5. Ghost of Planes - 8,5
6. If We Must Part Like This - 7,5
7. Undone - 8
8. Diminished - 9,5
9. The Top of the World - 9

How can I be free?
How can I get help?
Am I really me?
Am I someone else?

Sebastian Winter

tak na dobra sprawe powinnismy te plyte ocenić jeszcze raz bo teraz gdy wysluchallismy ja  ponad 2000 razy odbieramy ją zupelnie inaczej niz kiedyś....0=0 O0 :)
What can I say when, in some obscure way,
I am my own direction?

Hennos

Cytat: Sebastian Winter w 28 Lipiec 2009, 21:12:39
tak na dobra sprawe powinnismy te plyte ocenić jeszcze raz bo teraz gdy wysluchallismy ja  ponad 2000 razy odbieramy ją zupelnie inaczej niz kiedyś....0=0 O0 :)

Pewnie masz rację, ale ja swoich głosów nic a nic nie zmienię ;)
Without deviation from the norm, progress is not possible - F. Zappa.

Sebastian Winter

no ja tez - i tak wszystkim kompozycjom 10 dalem 0=0
What can I say when, in some obscure way,
I am my own direction?

ceizurac

Po 11 głosach:

The Mercy - 11,64 (128 p.)
The Top of the World Club - 9,82 (108 p.)
Your Face on the Street - 9,5 (104,5 p.)
Stumbled - 9,5 (104,5 p.)
Diminished - 9,5 (104,5 p.)
Wrong Way Round - 9,36 (103 p.)
Undone - 9,36 (103 p.)
If We Must Part Like this - 9,04 (99,5 p.)
Ghost of Planes - 8,95 (98,5 p.)

Średnia albumu - 9,64 (954,5 p./99)
There's the thing, hold it close.
You had your fling. You laid your ghosts.

Time to leave, close the door.
You can't believe you wanted more,
more or less, al for the best
in the end it's al behind you.

There's the thing, for all you know
it's time to let go.

Hajduk

Thin Air (2009)

1. The Mercy - 10
2. Your Face On The Street - 10
3. Stumbled - 10
4. Wrong Way Round - 10
5. Ghost Of Planes - 10
6. If We Must Part Like This - 10
7. Undone - 8,5
8. Diminished - 9,5 (znakomite zakończenie, znacznie ciekawsze od zasadniczej pieśni)
9. The Top of the World Club - 10



ceizurac

Po 12 głosach:

The Mercy - 11,5 (138 p.)
The Top of the World Club - 9,83 (118 p.)
Your Face on the Street - 9,54 (114,5 p.)
Stumbled - 9,54 (114,5 p.)
Diminished - 9,5 (114 p.)
Wrong Way Round - 9,42 (113 p.)
Undone - 9,29 (111,5 p.)
If We Must Part Like this - 9,125 (109,5 p.)
Ghost of Planes - 9,04 (108,5 p.)

Średnia albumu - 9,65 (1042,5 p./108)
There's the thing, hold it close.
You had your fling. You laid your ghosts.

Time to leave, close the door.
You can't believe you wanted more,
more or less, al for the best
in the end it's al behind you.

There's the thing, for all you know
it's time to let go.

Natalie

1. The Mercy - 12
2. Your Face on the Street - 10
3. Stumbled - 10
4. Wrong Way Round - 10
5. Ghost of Planes - 10
6. If We Must Part Like this - 10
7. Undone - 10
8. Diminished - 10
9. The Top of the World Club - 10
Some call me SATAN others have me GOD
some name me NEMO... I am unborn.

ceizurac

#25
Po 13 głosach:

The Mercy - 11,54 (150 p.)
The Top of the World Club - 9,85 (128 p.)
Your Face on the Street - 9,58 (124,5 p.)
Stumbled - 9,58 (124,5 p.)
Diminished - 9,54 (124 p.)
Wrong Way Round - 9,46 (123 p.)
Undone - 9,35 (121,5 p.)
If We Must Part Like this - 9,19 (119,5 p.)
Ghost of Planes - 9,11 (118,5 p.)

Średnia albumu - 9,7 (1134,5 p./117)
There's the thing, hold it close.
You had your fling. You laid your ghosts.

Time to leave, close the door.
You can't believe you wanted more,
more or less, al for the best
in the end it's al behind you.

There's the thing, for all you know
it's time to let go.

Black_Rose

1. The Mercy - 10
2. Your Face on the Street - 10
3. Stumbled - 10
4. Wrong Way Round - 10
5. Ghost of Planes - 10
6. If We Must Part Like this - 10
7. Undone - 9
8. Diminished - 10
9. The Top of the World Club - 10

ceizurac

Po 14 głosach:

The Mercy - 11,43 (160 p.)
The Top of the World Club - 9,86 (138 p.)
Your Face on the Street - 9,61 (134,5 p.)
Stumbled - 9, (134,5 p.)
Diminished - 9,57 (134 p.)
Wrong Way Round - 9,5 (133 p.)
Undone - 9,32 (130,5 p.)
If We Must Part Like this - 9,25 (129,5 p.)
Ghost of Planes - 9,17 (128,5 p.)

Średnia albumu - 9,71 (1223,5 p./126)
There's the thing, hold it close.
You had your fling. You laid your ghosts.

Time to leave, close the door.
You can't believe you wanted more,
more or less, al for the best
in the end it's al behind you.

There's the thing, for all you know
it's time to let go.